Court Dismisses Nursing Home’s Claim that Daughter Is Responsible for Father's Bill, and Daughter’s Countersuit Is Settled

The daughter of a New Jersey nursing home resident successfully defended against a lawsuit by the nursing home alleging that she was liable for her father's care, according to an article on NJ.com.

When Tracey Mitchell admitted her father to a nursing home, according to the article, she signed the admissions agreement, which contained a clause holding her personally responsible for charges that were not covered by her father's assets or Medicaid. Ms. Mitchell applied for Medicaid on her father's behalf, and he began receiving benefits, but a portion of his bill remained uncovered by Medicaid.

The nursing home filed a lawsuit against Ms. Mitchell, alleging that she owed the facility $49,000. According to the article, Ms. Mitchell countersued for consumer fraud, arguing that the clause in the admissions contract making Ms. Mitchell personally liable is illegal under state and federal law. The court dismissed the case against Ms. Mitchell, and the countersuit has been settled. The court did not issue a written opinion in the case.

"I am hoping this case will send a message to nursing homes that they can't file these illegal lawsuits against the children of their residents," Ms. Mitchell told NJ.com. "How many people just pay because they do not know it is illegal?"

To read the NJ.com article about the case, click here.